All Insurance

Rim Country Coverage

Landlord Insurance

Renting out a home, cabin, or second property in the Rim Country? A landlord policy protects the building, your liability as an owner, and the rental income you count on — coverage a standard homeowners policy won't provide once tenants move in.

What's covered

What landlord insurance includes

Rental-dwelling property coverage
Landlord liability for tenant & guest injury
Loss of rental income after a covered loss
Short-term / vacation-rental considerations
Coverage for cabins and second homes
Multi-property and bundled options
01

Landlord insurance for Rim Country rentals

Rim Country has a lot of rental property — long-term rentals in Payson and Star Valley, cabins in Pine and Strawberry, and vacation rentals scattered across the forest. The moment you rent a property to someone else, your exposure changes, and a standard homeowners policy generally won't cover a home you don't live in or one used as a rental. Landlord insurance is built for owners who rent, and as a local agency we match it to how your property is actually used — long-term lease, seasonal, or short-term vacation rental.

02

What landlord insurance covers

A landlord policy protects the rental dwelling and other structures against covered perils like fire, wind, and hail; provides landlord liability if a tenant or guest is injured on the property and you're held responsible; and — importantly — covers loss of rental income if a covered loss makes the property uninhabitable while it's repaired. It protects your interest as the owner; your tenants' belongings are their responsibility, which is why many landlords require tenants to carry renters insurance. We'll explain where your coverage ends and the tenant's begins.

03

Long-term, seasonal, and vacation rentals

How you rent changes what you need. A long-term lease is the most straightforward. A cabin or second home that sits empty part of the year has vacancy considerations. And a short-term vacation rental — increasingly common up here — brings higher turnover, more guests, and often a need for specific short-term-rental coverage that a standard landlord policy may not fully address. We make sure the policy matches your rental model so a claim isn't denied because the carrier didn't know how the property was being used.

04

Protecting your rental income

For many Rim Country owners, rental income is part of the plan — covering a mortgage, supplementing retirement, or making a second home pay for itself. If a covered loss takes the property out of service, the lost rent can hurt as much as the damage. Landlord policies can include loss-of-rents coverage that replaces that income while the property is repaired, so a fire or major storm doesn't blow a hole in your finances on top of the repair bill. We'll size it to your actual rental income.

05

Multiple properties, one local agency

If you own more than one rental — or a mix of a primary home, a cabin, and a rental or two — managing separate policies with separate companies is a headache. As an independent agency we can place all of them, look for multi-policy savings, and give you one point of contact who knows your whole portfolio. One renewal conversation, one person to call, and coverage that's coordinated across everything you own.

Why Payson Insurance Agency

Local insurance from people who live here too.

A Rim Country brand of Contractors Choice Agency — a licensed Arizona independent agency that shops carriers for you and treats you like a neighbor.

We know Rim Country

Wildfire in the pines, monsoon storms, elk on the highway, winter at elevation — we build coverage around the way you actually live up here, not a generic national checklist.

Independent — we work for you

We shop multiple carriers on your behalf instead of pushing one company's products, so you get options, honest comparisons, and the right coverage at the right price.

Everything under one roof

Home, auto, business, landlord, and renters — all with one local agency. Bundle to simplify your paperwork and often lower your premium.

A real person who answers

Call and reach someone who knows the area and your account — not a call center. Claims help, coverage questions, and renewals handled like a neighbor.

Answers

Landlord Insurance — FAQs

Straight answers to the questions Rim Country folks ask us most about this coverage.

Because a standard homeowners policy is designed for an owner-occupied home and generally won't cover a property you rent to others or don't live in. Once tenants move in, your exposure changes — different liability, loss of rental income, and tenant-related risks that a homeowners policy isn't built for. Using a homeowners policy on a rental can leave you with a denied claim when you need it most. Landlord insurance is the right coverage for a rental property.

A landlord policy covers the rental dwelling and other structures against covered perils like fire, wind, and hail; provides landlord liability if someone is injured on the property and you're responsible; and can cover loss of rental income if a covered loss makes the property uninhabitable while it's repaired. It protects your interest as the owner — your tenants' personal belongings are covered by their own renters insurance, not your landlord policy.

Yes, and it's increasingly common in the Rim Country. Short-term and vacation rentals bring higher guest turnover and exposures that a standard landlord policy may not fully address, so they often need specific short-term-rental coverage. We'll match the policy to how you actually rent — whether that's a long-term lease, a seasonal cabin, or a busy vacation rental — so your coverage holds up at claim time.

It's a smart move, and many landlords do. Your landlord policy covers the building and your liability as the owner, but not your tenants' personal belongings — those are the tenant's responsibility. Requiring renters insurance protects your tenants, reduces disputes after a loss, and can even reduce your exposure. We can write affordable renters policies for your tenants too, keeping everything with one local agency.

It can, through loss-of-rents (or fair-rental-value) coverage, which replaces the rental income you lose when a covered loss makes the property uninhabitable while it's being repaired. For owners who count on that income for a mortgage or as part of their plan, it's an important protection. We'll size it to your actual rental income so a covered loss doesn't take both the property and the income at once.

Yes. As an independent agency we can place coverage on multiple properties, look for multi-policy savings, and give you one point of contact who knows your whole portfolio — whether it's a couple of long-term rentals or a mix of a primary home, a cabin, and vacation rentals. One renewal conversation and one agent beats juggling separate policies with separate companies.

It's a consideration we'll address rather than a dealbreaker. Properties that sit vacant for stretches have specific exposures — and standard policies sometimes limit coverage during vacancy — so it's important the policy is written knowing how the property is used. Tell us the seasonal pattern and any monitoring or caretaking in place, and we'll structure coverage that keeps the cabin protected year-round.

Call 844-967-5247 or fill out the quote form with details on the property — where it is, how it's used (long-term, seasonal, or short-term rental), and your approximate rental income. We'll shop carriers and get back to you, usually the same day, with options and clear explanations. Quotes are free and carry no obligation.

Still have questions? Call 844-967-5247

Let's find you better coverage — right here at home.

Tell us about your home, vehicles, or business and we'll shop the carriers for you. Free, no-obligation quote — usually same day.

Local independent agency · Serving Payson & Arizona's Rim Country · Mon–Fri 8am–5pm