About Us
Your hometown insurance agency for the Rim Country
Payson Insurance Agency is a local independent agency serving Payson and Arizona's Rim Country — home, auto, business, landlord, and renters coverage from neighbors who know the area and work for you, not one carrier.
Who we are
Local service, backed by an established agency
Payson Insurance Agency is a Rim Country brand of Contractors Choice Agency, an independent insurance agency founded in 2005 and licensed in Arizona. We pair the carrier access and backing of an established agency with the local knowledge and personal service of a hometown office.
Because we're independent, we don't answer to a single insurance company. We shop multiple carriers on your behalf, compare coverage and price, and bring you honest options — then we stay with you through claims, renewals, and the changes life brings.
Most of all, we know the Rim Country, because it's home. The risks up here — wildfire, monsoon storms, wildlife on the highways, winter at 5,000 feet — aren't line items in a national quote engine to us. They're the reasons we do this work the way we do.
5 lines
Personal & business coverage
20+
Years of agency experience
Multi
Carriers shopped for you
1-day
Quote turnaround
How we work
What you can expect from us
We know Rim Country
We understand wildfire in the pines, monsoon storms, elk on SR-260, and winter at elevation — and we build coverage around the way you actually live up here.
Independent — we work for you
We're not tied to one company. We shop multiple carriers on your behalf and give you honest comparisons, so you get options and the right price.
Everything under one roof
Home, auto, business, landlord, and renters — all with one local agency. Bundle to simplify your coverage and often lower your premium.
We're here for the long haul
Claims help, renewals, and coverage reviews as your life and business change — handled by a real person who knows your account and treats you like a neighbor.
Let's find you better coverage — right here at home.
Tell us about your home, vehicles, or business and we'll shop the carriers for you. Free, no-obligation quote — usually same day.
Local independent agency · Serving Payson & Arizona's Rim Country · Mon–Fri 8am–5pm